Pelfrey Insurance and Financial Services, Inc.

About Us

I’m Anthony Pelfrey, an Ohio-based entrepreneur, veteran, and relationship-driven business owner. I own and operate a full-service insurance and financial services agency built on trust, clarity, and long-term relationships. My focus is helping individuals, families, and business owners protect what they’ve worked for while planning confidently for what’s ahead.

At the core of my work is conversation. I believe the best decisions come from understanding people, not pushing products. I take a personalized, straight-forward approach across auto, home, life, health, business insurance, and retirement planning. Education matters to me. I want clients to understand their options, feel confident in their choices, and know they have someone in their corner for the long haul.

I’m married to my wife, Alex, a Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner who serves individuals and families across Ohio. Together, we’re raising four kids and navigating life with a strong emphasis on communication, accountability, and balance. One of our children attends Otterbein University, a reminder that planning for the future isn’t theoretical for me. It’s personal.

Whether I’m leading teams, serving clients, or mentoring others, my approach stays consistent: be present, be honest, and lead with solutions. I’m deeply family-oriented, community-minded, and committed to building businesses rooted in integrity, growth, and genuine care for the people we serve.